Just got home from watching the last movie of the FreedomFilmFest2009 at The Annexe, Central Market. The film was called A Jihad for Love, a film showing the discrimination against homosexual Muslims of different countries, and as a result of religious persecution they had to flee their own homeland. Personally, I found the film kinda boring. Only because halfway I realized i was seeing the same images over and over again. However, the issues that were highlighted were very real and includes the personal dilemma of being a homosexual and a Muslim too, while it is generally known that in Islam, homosexuality is haram.
There was a Q&A session that took place right after the show where several audience members gave their own views how sexuality fits into religion and vice versa. Generally, the sentiments that were shared suggested that people accepted homosexuality. There was this one chinese lady however who had a different opinion. Before I continue, let me just say that FFF has always believed in dialogue among the people, and they create this 'sharing' platform by engaging the audience to react to human rights films that are shown. Now in this case, this particular lady (who was a counselor who worked with kids that had sexuality issues) boldly stood up and shared her thoughts on why a person 'became' homosexual (based on her experience with the kids she counsels) and her reasons had to do with them having a traumatic childhood or who came from broken homes. She even referred to homosexuality as a 'disease'. At this point, most of the people in the hall were talking underneath their breaths clearly upset by her remarks. It seemed as if she was still living in the stone age. What happened next was predictable. A few ppl stood up and rebutted, and as a result, she and her fellow kawan quietly excused themselves from the room.
I was so upset. Because here we are trying to engage ppl to share their thoughts and opinions on the issues and it was obvious that this particular lady was the minority in the group and for her to feel uncomfortable, embarrassed, upset or even threatened by the ppl in the hall was totally uncalled for.
What I should've done was stand up and say to her and the rest of the crowd is this "Thank you for being bold enough to share your thoughts. I totally respect you and your opinions but I also totally disagree with it.
However, I know that you may feel uncomfortable or upset but the outlash of some of the folks here, but I sincerely hope that you stay til the end and hear what the others have to say and who knows, maybe you'll learn a new thing or two. And if you still believe that homosexuality is a disease that can be cured, then that's your right. I think its wrong, but it is your right."
Of course i didnt say this cuz by the time i was able to put my thoughts together, the Q&A was over and all I could do was go up to the facilitator and tell this to him instead.
Frankly, the point of having these discussions is so that everyone feels that they have a safe space to speak. Unfortunately that lady didn't feel safe and its a shame really.
Now if you ask me personally, what my feelings are about the movie, well, its a mix really. I am a Muslim and I was brought up to believe that if you are a homosexual, you will go to hell. However, it's really hard for me to accept that because what if you're a good human being, you pray 5 times a day, you give to charity, you help the poor, you are selfless and you contribute to society, and just because you prefer to love and make love to a person of the same sex, you are condemned to hell? I dunno, thats a tough one for me.
At the same time I think, when God created humans, he created Adam and Eve first. A male and a female. Not Adam and Bob.Or Eve and Lisa. He created this pair to reproduce and in turn start civilizations on earth. That is how humanity started. From my understanding. Lets not get into the whole theory of evolution as that will involve opening a huge can of worms. Anyway, I suppose along the way, Bob and Lisa turned up and well, humanity became more diverse.
At the end of it all, I believe that the universal values of love, compassion, kindness, understanding is what we should focus on. There's too much hate, anger, jealousy, greed in the world now. So why perpetuate it?